P1225 mounting external antenna
Moderator: Queue Moderator
P1225 mounting external antenna
I would like to mount an external antenna on my P1225. I have a MX-threaded adapter, but this radio does not have a "grounding ring" at the antenna connector.
I'm not real strong on electronics, but my idea was to run a stranded 18-gage wire from the antenna adapter to the ground plate on the underside where the battery connects.
After a series of trials, what I observed was:
- The external antenna does put out some unquantifiable amount of RF, as evidenced by a simple diode-based meter;
- However, it puts out *more* RF if I disconnect the ground wire altogether;
- While I am running the setup through a wattmeter, it measures only 1 watt out, then jumps up to 2 watts when I remove that ground wire;
- Curiosly, I got the same results with one of my HT600s, which I know puts out a full 5 watts when mounted in its Converta-com;
- And yes, the battery is good, the threaded connection is tight, and the radio does otherwise put out enough RF to peg the hand-held meter when used with its rubber ducky.
Obviously, I do not know the best practices in improvising an external antenna, though I have read posts on the Batboard where the late Monty briefly alluded to a special harness he made for the purpose of grounding external antennas.
Can anyone make suggestions as to the theory involved, what kind of implementation "ought" to work, what kinds of wire should I use for this purpose, etc.?
Tim
I'm not real strong on electronics, but my idea was to run a stranded 18-gage wire from the antenna adapter to the ground plate on the underside where the battery connects.
After a series of trials, what I observed was:
- The external antenna does put out some unquantifiable amount of RF, as evidenced by a simple diode-based meter;
- However, it puts out *more* RF if I disconnect the ground wire altogether;
- While I am running the setup through a wattmeter, it measures only 1 watt out, then jumps up to 2 watts when I remove that ground wire;
- Curiosly, I got the same results with one of my HT600s, which I know puts out a full 5 watts when mounted in its Converta-com;
- And yes, the battery is good, the threaded connection is tight, and the radio does otherwise put out enough RF to peg the hand-held meter when used with its rubber ducky.
Obviously, I do not know the best practices in improvising an external antenna, though I have read posts on the Batboard where the late Monty briefly alluded to a special harness he made for the purpose of grounding external antennas.
Can anyone make suggestions as to the theory involved, what kind of implementation "ought" to work, what kinds of wire should I use for this purpose, etc.?
Tim
- HLA
- Posts: 2334
- Joined: Mon Jul 11, 2005 8:15 pm
- What radios do you own?: HT1550's, X9000's, CDM1550's
if it's recieve only then it probablly won't make a difference on the ground but if you have to transmit then i'd find a mobile to use.
HLA
I never check PM's so don't bother, just email me.
I won't reply to a hotmail, gmail, aol or any other generic free address, if you want me to reply use a real address.
STOP ASKING ME FOR SOFTWARE OR FIRMWARE, I JUST FORWARD ALL OF THE REQUESTS TO THE MODERATORS
I never check PM's so don't bother, just email me.
I won't reply to a hotmail, gmail, aol or any other generic free address, if you want me to reply use a real address.
STOP ASKING ME FOR SOFTWARE OR FIRMWARE, I JUST FORWARD ALL OF THE REQUESTS TO THE MODERATORS
I'm going to bump myself here, with a bit more info. Another post on the Batboard describes what I'm attempting to do:
http://batboard.batlabs.com/viewtopic.php?t=23300
In that post, one of the members describes a commercially-available adapter for the MT-1000 that "sort of screws in and has a grounding strap that somehow is wedged between the housing and the frame or shield."
Monty replied that he had made " 'Special' Adaptors for the HT600 / P200 / MT1000 series," unfortunately the images he posted are no longer available from the external server.
I have a hunch that the ground strap cannot be made from simply any wire, but I am not sure exactly what is called for (how wide or thick)... or, how to get just a short piece of it! I also imagine that it must be as short as possible; but how long is too long when dealing with UHF?
Anyone who has one of these adapters, your description will be most welcome!
To clarify HLA's question, this radio must receive and transmit. Also, because the external antenna has a stacked design, I believe it must be grounded in order to have gain on receive. (The antenna works quite effectively with my scanner, which has a grounded BNC-type post...)
Thanks for your thoughts,
Tim
http://batboard.batlabs.com/viewtopic.php?t=23300
In that post, one of the members describes a commercially-available adapter for the MT-1000 that "sort of screws in and has a grounding strap that somehow is wedged between the housing and the frame or shield."
Monty replied that he had made " 'Special' Adaptors for the HT600 / P200 / MT1000 series," unfortunately the images he posted are no longer available from the external server.
I have a hunch that the ground strap cannot be made from simply any wire, but I am not sure exactly what is called for (how wide or thick)... or, how to get just a short piece of it! I also imagine that it must be as short as possible; but how long is too long when dealing with UHF?
Anyone who has one of these adapters, your description will be most welcome!
To clarify HLA's question, this radio must receive and transmit. Also, because the external antenna has a stacked design, I believe it must be grounded in order to have gain on receive. (The antenna works quite effectively with my scanner, which has a grounded BNC-type post...)
Thanks for your thoughts,
Tim
The P1225 does in fact have a grounding ring at the top of the radio housing. If you remove the antenna and look at it from the top, you had better see a metal ring. Internally, it makes a good ground contact with the chassis. With the proper adaptor you should read full power at that point and have no problem.
BJ
BJ
Yesterday it worked. Today it is not working. Windows is like that
Thanks for the tip. This is my first P1225, so I had nothing to compare it to when I purchased it and noticed that it doesn't have a grounding ring.llu727 wrote:The P1225 does in fact have a grounding ring at the top of the radio housing. If you remove the antenna and look at it from the top, you had better see a metal ring.
BJ

(There is a recessed flat under the antenna where such a ring might go, but none is present.)
And now I recall the words of the seller: "mint condition... has been professionally re-cased."

Any suggestions what I might try next to get a good solid ground? Is RF ground different in any way than electrical ground?
Tim
that little ring not being there is your problem.. if it was recased, that explains it. Its only a couple penny part, to the best of my recollection, but you have to take the escutcheon off and the radio outof the housing to put it on. It makes a pretty solid RF ground to the metal frame. Dont have a manual here to look up part numbers, but even replacing the escutcheon, I would guess at less than $2.
Not sure which RF adaptor you are using, but with that one part it will work fine. Obviously the stud has to be inulated from the ground on the adaptor.
BJ
Not sure which RF adaptor you are using, but with that one part it will work fine. Obviously the stud has to be inulated from the ground on the adaptor.
BJ
Yesterday it worked. Today it is not working. Windows is like that
Hey Guys, I stand corrected, sorry.
Last edited by Will on Sun Apr 08, 2007 2:39 pm, edited 1 time in total.